The Turkey Problem: Taleb's Thanksgiving Warning About Being Fed Every Day

The turkey problem is Nassim Taleb's parable of a bird fed every day until Thanksgiving: a calm track record can raise confidence just as risk peaks.

Share
A stitched patchwork bunny doll in a pilgrim hat scattering corn for a plump stitched turkey doll in a neon-lit cyberpunk barnyard, with a dark farmhouse door glowing ajar in the background

The turkey problem is Nassim Nicholas Taleb's parable about learning from a calm past: a turkey is fed every day, grows more sure that humans are "looking out for its best interests," and is proven wrong on the Wednesday before Thanksgiving.2 The lesson is that a long stretch without trouble is not proof of safety, because the data cannot show you an event that has not happened yet.1 2

What is Taleb's turkey problem?

In The Black Swan, Taleb asks readers to picture a turkey that is fed every day: each meal firms up the bird's belief that being fed is "the general rule of life," until "the afternoon of the Wednesday before Thanksgiving," when the turkey "will incur a revision of belief."2 In a 2011 Foreign Affairs essay with Mark Blyth, he gives the bird 1,000 days of feeding, each one seeming to confirm that the farmer cares for it, with confidence at its maximum on the last day.1

Taleb and Blyth say the turkey problem arises when people read stability off a history with no past swings.1 In plain English: no bad surprises so far feels like evidence of no bad surprises ahead.1

Where did the turkey come from?

The logic is older than the bird. In The Problems of Philosophy (1912), Bertrand Russell wrote that "the man who has fed the chicken every day throughout its life at last wrings its neck instead," and that the chicken could have used "more refined views as to the uniformity of nature."3 Russell's point was about induction, the habit of expecting that what happened many times will happen again.3

Could a real turkey even be fed for 1,000 days?

No, which is part of the fun: the 1,000 days is a thought experiment.1 The National Turkey Federation says a commercial hen usually takes 14 weeks to reach processing weight and a tom grows for 18 weeks.4

Taleb's turkeyA commercial turkey
How long it is fed1,000 days1About 14 weeks (hen) or 18 weeks (tom)4
What it concludesThe farmer cares for it1Nothing: it is a thought experiment about people, not birds1
How it endsThe Wednesday before Thanksgiving2Processing at market weight4

The farm timeline is a prop; the parable works because the turkey stands in for anyone holding a long, clean track record.1

Why does a calm streak feel like safety?

Taleb writes: "Consider that [the turkey's] feeling of safety reached its maximum when the risk was at the highest!"2 A CNBC column from Thanksgiving week 2012 adds a second trap, hindsight: it is easy to say the turkey should have asked why it was being fed, but that reasoning projects backward a pattern the turkey could not have seen.5 The column says we repeat the turkey's mistake whenever we credit the past with more predictive power than it has.5

What does the turkey problem look like in money?

In a February 20, 2004 speech on the period economists call the Great Moderation, Federal Reserve Governor Ben Bernanke noted that the variability of quarterly output growth had fallen by half since the mid-1980s and the variability of quarterly inflation by about two thirds.6 Those numbers were real, and his talk was a careful account of why volatility had fallen.6 The economy then peaked in December 2007.7 From peak to trough, US GDP fell 4.3 percent and the unemployment rate rose from under 5 percent to 10 percent, in what the Federal Reserve describes as the deepest recession since World War II.7

Taleb and Blyth argue that confidence in stability was at its maximum at the onset of the 2007 financial crisis.1 For the math of why tails behave differently, see fat tails, and for the bigger family of surprises, black swan events.

How do you avoid being the turkey?

Taleb's own framing is modest. Taleb writes, "In a way, all I care about is making a decision without being the turkey."5 These habits follow from the parable, as general education and not personalized financial advice:

  • Ask which event you have not yet experienced would do real damage, and plan for that rather than for a typical year.
  • Treat a long calm streak as a reason to check your assumptions, not to relax them.
  • Keep a cash cushion and avoid borrowed money that a single bad month could force you to unwind.
  • Check whether a model or news feed is showing you just the recent past; our piece on why your risk model is your news feed covers the trap.

The same habit travels. A relationship, a job or a budget with a spotless record can still deserve a "what if" talk, and our guide to how to be antifragile is a good place to start. Eat well, and keep your own surprises small.

─────────

Sources:

  1. Taleb, Nassim Nicholas and Mark Blyth. "The Black Swan of Cairo." Foreign Affairs, May/June 2011, p. 35. May/June 2011
  2. Udland, Myles. "NASSIM TALEB: Consider The Thanksgiving Turkey..." Business Insider, November 25, 2014, quoting Taleb, The Black Swan (2007). businessinsider.com
  3. Russell, Bertrand. The Problems of Philosophy, 1912, chapter VI, "On Induction." wikisource.org
  4. National Turkey Federation. "Frequently Asked Questions About Raising Turkey," posted January 2019. eatturkey.org
  5. "Black Swans and Turkeys." CNBC, November 23, 2012, quoting Taleb. cnbc.com
  6. Bernanke, Ben S. "The Great Moderation," remarks at the Eastern Economic Association, Washington, DC, February 20, 2004. federalreserve.gov
  7. Weinberg, John. "The Great Recession and Its Aftermath." Federal Reserve History, written as of November 22, 2013. federalreservehistory.org

MoneySexNerd on Substack

The rabbit hole goes deeper.

This page is the field guide. The Substack is where the bunny gets weird: longer essays on sex, money and nerd culture, with more research, more opinions and nothing watered down for search engines.

Go deeper on Substack →

Free to read. Unsubscribe whenever.